Thumbtack jokes
You're shorter than a thumbtack, like, boy, your auntie is probably taller than you.
Stephanie has a great thumb!
Some people call them glue sticks, but they're blue sticks.
If you're feeling numb, use your thumb.
What nails do carpenters hate to hit?
Thumb nails.
At the bar last night, a woman got her nipple pierced right in front of me.
On a related note, I suck at darts.